Billy Joel is one of the most successful recording artists in American music history, with a run of Billboard hits that spanned more than two decades. From the early 1970s through the late 1980s, his songs regularly dominated the charts, balancing pop accessibility with sharp storytelling and musical ambition. This article ranks Billy Joel’s top songs based strictly on Billboard performance, focusing on peak positions, chart longevity, and historical impact.
Howard Dee’s Take
Billy Joel has been the soundtrack to my life in a way that’s hard to explain to someone who didn’t grow up with him always “there.” His songs weren’t just hits playing in the background—they were markers in time. I can hear a piano intro and instantly I’m back in a car, in a living room, at a party, or just alone with my own thoughts, because his music somehow fit all of it: the good years, the stressful years, the “what am I doing with my life?” years, and the years where you feel like you finally figured a few things out.
What I’ve always loved about Billy is that he made songs that felt human—not manufactured, not trying to impress you with coolness, but built to tell the truth in a way people could live inside. Even when he’s writing something playful, there’s usually a real emotional engine underneath it. And when he’s writing something heavy, he does it without turning it into melodrama. That combination—craft, honesty, and accessibility—is why his Billboard run matters to me: those charts weren’t rewarding a gimmick, they were reflecting the fact that millions of people were living their lives with the same songs in their ears.
1. We Didn’t Start the Fire (Storm Front, 1989)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“We Didn’t Start the Fire” reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1989 and remained at the top for two consecutive weeks, making it one of the most commercially powerful singles of Billy Joel’s career. What makes that achievement notable is timing. By the late 1980s, many artists who had defined the 1970s were no longer competitive on contemporary pop radio, yet Joel managed to deliver a song that didn’t just chart well—it dominated.
This ranking is reinforced by how unconventional the song was for a No. 1 hit. There is no traditional chorus, no romantic hook, and no radio-friendly repetition. Instead, it relied on lyrical velocity and cultural recognition. Its Billboard performance reflects not just airplay, but cultural saturation: people talked about it, debated it, and kept listening, which sustained its chart run despite its atypical structure.
Howard Dee’s Take
I still remember the first time I heard this song, and my reaction wasn’t admiration—it was confusion. It didn’t sound like a normal Billy Joel track, and it didn’t feel built to be a hit. But that confusion is what pulled me back. It felt urgent, like someone trying to say everything at once before time ran out, and that sense of urgency stuck with me.
What’s changed over time is how heavy it feels. When I was younger, it sounded clever and fast, almost like a challenge to keep up. Now it feels more like a reminder of how quickly history piles up. I don’t hear it as nostalgia; I hear it as momentum, and that makes it hit harder today than it ever did back then.
2. It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me (Glass Houses, 1980)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me” reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1980 and held the top position for two weeks, making it one of the strongest chart performers of Billy Joel’s career. It arrived at a moment when Joel was already established, but still under pressure to evolve with changing musical trends. The song’s success wasn’t just about peak position—it marked his ability to dominate the charts while openly questioning the very idea of trend-chasing.
Its Billboard impact is amplified by how quickly it connected with listeners. The track climbed fast, received heavy radio rotation, and resonated across demographics that were already starting to fragment in the early 1980s. In a period when disco backlash and new-wave experimentation were reshaping pop radio, this song cut through by being direct, catchy, and self-aware. Billboard rewarded that clarity, and the song’s chart run reflects both commercial momentum and cultural timing.
Howard Dee’s Take
When I heard this song at 16, I wasn’t thinking about trends, music criticism, or permission to like what I liked. I heard it as fast, loud, confident, and a little defiant — the kind of song that made you feel like you were on the inside of something cool. It felt cocky in a fun way, like Billy Joel was grinning at the world and daring it to keep up. At that age, that was enough.
What’s interesting is how the song changes meaning over time. Back then, it was about attitude and energy. Now, it sounds like someone who’s already seen the cycle repeat a few times and knows how temporary “what’s hot” really is. The song didn’t change — I did. And that’s part of what makes Billy Joel different from a lot of artists: his songs don’t outgrow you, they wait for you to catch up.
3. Tell Her About It (An Innocent Man, 1983)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“Tell Her About It” reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1983, giving Billy Joel his second chart-topper of the 1980s and confirming that his commercial peak extended well beyond the 1970s. By this point, Joel wasn’t just surviving in a new musical decade — he was still shaping mainstream pop. The song’s quick rise and strong radio rotation made it one of the defining singles of An Innocent Man, an album that deliberately leaned into early rock and soul influences while still sounding contemporary.
What strengthens this song’s ranking is how cleanly it fit into Billboard’s ecosystem at the time. It worked across pop and adult-contemporary radio, had a concise, hook-driven structure, and carried a message that was instantly relatable. In a year crowded with synth-heavy and stylistically flashy hits, “Tell Her About It” succeeded by being direct and emotionally legible. Its No. 1 status reflects not novelty, but broad appeal and repeat listening — the kind of success that only comes from a song that radio trusts.
Howard Dee’s Take
When I heard this song at 19, I didn’t hear it as nostalgia or throwback soul or anything clever like that. I heard it as instructions. Plain and simple. It felt like Billy Joel was laying out a basic roadmap for how you were supposed to treat a woman, especially when you were young, unsure of yourself, and trying not to screw things up. It wasn’t abstract — it was practical.
What’s stuck with me is how straightforward it is without being preachy. There’s no big speech, no emotional manipulation, just a reminder that honesty and effort actually matter. Looking back, I realize how rare that kind of message was in pop music at the time. A lot of songs were about conquest or heartbreak; this one was about responsibility. And at that age, that mattered more than I probably realized.
4. Uptown Girl (An Innocent Man, 1983)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“Uptown Girl” peaked at No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 in late 1983 and became one of the longest-lasting and most commercially visible singles of Billy Joel’s career. While it didn’t reach No. 1 in the U.S., its sustained chart presence, massive radio airplay, and crossover success made it one of the defining pop songs of the decade. It also performed strongly internationally, further amplifying its overall Billboard-era impact.
What pushes this song high in the rankings is endurance rather than peak position alone. “Uptown Girl” stayed in heavy rotation well beyond its chart run, helped by its instantly recognizable doo-wop revival style and broad demographic appeal. In the context of An Innocent Man, it showed Joel’s ability to fully commit to a retro sound without it feeling like novelty. Billboard rewarded that commitment because the song worked — repeatedly — with listeners who didn’t care about homage, only whether the record made them hit repeat.
Howard Dee’s Take
What I remember most about this song isn’t the retro sound or how big it was on the radio — it’s the video and seeing Christie Brinkley in it. At the time, she was everywhere, and watching Billy Joel paired with someone who looked like that made the song feel almost autobiographical. It didn’t come across as fantasy to me; it came across as disbelief. Like Billy himself couldn’t quite believe his luck.
That’s how I’ve always heard the song since. Not as a guy chasing an “uptown girl,” but as a guy standing there thinking, How did I pull this off? There’s a humility baked into it that people sometimes miss. It’s playful, sure, but it also feels genuine — like admiration more than desire. And knowing that Christie Brinkley was his real-life partner at the time just makes the whole thing land even better.
5. Just the Way You Are (The Stranger, 1977)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“Just the Way You Are” peaked at No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 in early 1978, but its real strength comes from longevity and crossover dominance. The song spent 22 weeks on the Hot 100, performed exceptionally well on adult contemporary radio, and became one of the records that permanently expanded Billy Joel’s audience beyond rock and pop listeners. It was also the song that earned Joel his first two Grammy Awards (Record of the Year and Song of the Year), reinforcing its industry impact alongside its chart performance.
This song ranks high not because it was flashy, but because it changed the trajectory of his career. Before this, Joel was respected and rising; after it, he was mainstream and trusted across formats. Billboard performance here reflects consistency rather than peak — steady airplay, broad appeal, and long-term relevance. Songs like this are the backbone of a catalog, and Billboard history consistently rewards records that stay useful long after their initial climb.
Howard Dee’s Take
I’ve never counted this among my favorite Billy Joel songs, even though I fully understand why it ranks this high. From a Billboard and career standpoint, it’s undeniable — but emotionally, it was never the one I reached for. For a long time, it felt almost too polished for my taste, like a song that worked better on paper than in my gut.
That’s changed as I’ve gotten older. Now, when I hear it, I don’t think about Billy Joel at all — I picture my fiancée. I hear the line about loving someone just the way they are and think about the things that make her who she is, including the imperfections that are part of the deal. The song didn’t grow on me musically; it grew on me personally. And that’s a different kind of appreciation, one I didn’t expect but genuinely feel.
6. You May Be Right (Glass Houses, 1980)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“You May Be Right” peaked at No. 7 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1980 and became one of the most radio-dominant singles of Billy Joel’s career, even without reaching the Top 5. It was the lead single from Glass Houses, an album that marked a deliberate shift toward a harder, more guitar-driven sound. That context matters: this song didn’t just chart well, it announced a stylistic pivot — and Billboard rewarded that risk with sustained airplay and strong chart longevity.
Its placement here reflects impact rather than peak position alone. “You May Be Right” helped redefine Joel’s public image at the start of the 1980s, positioning him as something closer to a rock artist than a piano-based pop singer. It became a staple on rock radio as well as pop formats, which extended its life far beyond its initial chart run. Songs that successfully reset an artist’s trajectory tend to rank high in Billboard legacy, and this one clearly did.
Howard Dee’s Take
When I hear this song, I hear Billy Joel making a statement. He’d already proven he could write sophisticated, piano-driven hits with The Stranger and 52nd Street, and this feels like him saying, Don’t get comfortable — I’m not just that guy. This is Billy deliberately leaning into a harder edge, trying to show that he could stand toe-to-toe with rock artists, not just crooners or singer-songwriters.
What makes it work is that he doesn’t abandon what he’s good at. The lyrics are still sharp and clever, but now they’re delivered with attitude and momentum. It’s the kind of song that makes you move without thinking about it, and that’s the point. You can hear the confidence in it — not forced, not costume-like — just Billy Joel proving he had another gear and wasn’t afraid to use it.
7. My Life (52nd Street, 1978)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“My Life” peaked at No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1979 and became one of the defining singles from 52nd Street, the album that followed Billy Joel’s massive breakthrough with The Stranger. By this point, Joel wasn’t fighting for acceptance — he was managing expectations. This song’s strong chart performance showed that audiences were still fully engaged with him even as he shifted from confessional storytelling to something more declarative and self-assured.
Its ranking is driven by consistency and cultural durability. While it didn’t hit No. 1, it spent significant time on the charts and became a radio staple that outlived its original release cycle. Billboard success here reflects a song that resonated with listeners who were starting to define themselves independently — professionally, personally, and socially. It wasn’t just popular in the moment; it became a long-term anthem for personal autonomy, which kept it relevant well beyond its chart peak.
Howard Dee’s Take
I always associate this song with Bosom Buddies. Hearing it as the title song to that show locked it into my head early on, and every time it came on, it brought that same burst of energy with it. It felt upbeat, confident, and a little mischievous — the kind of song that immediately puts you in a good mood. Even before I thought about albums or chart positions, this one just moved.
What really stands out to me now is how perfectly it sets the tone for 52nd Street. There’s momentum in this song — a sense that Billy Joel was riding a wave and knew exactly where he was going. It’s not weighed down by introspection; it’s forward-looking and alive. That energy carries through the album, and this song feels like the front door — once it starts, you’re in.
8. Piano Man (Piano Man, 1973)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“Piano Man” peaked at No. 25 on the Billboard Hot 100 in early 1974, which on paper puts it well below many of Billy Joel’s biggest hits. But Billboard rankings aren’t just about peak position — they’re also about endurance, recurrence, and long-term chart life, and this is where “Piano Man” earns its place. Over time, it became Joel’s signature song, returning repeatedly to radio playlists, recurrent charts, and Billboard-era cultural tallies in a way few songs ever do.
What elevates this song in a Billboard-based ranking is that it outperformed its original chart run. It became a staple on album-oriented rock radio, adult contemporary stations, and live-performance setlists for decades. Billboard history consistently treats songs like this differently: tracks that grow into defining records often rank higher in legacy impact than their initial Hot 100 peaks suggest. “Piano Man” didn’t explode immediately — it accumulated authority, and that long-term dominance matters.
Howard Dee’s Take
This is the song that defined Billy Joel. It’s the story, the setting, the characters — all of it. No matter how many times I’ve heard it, I never get tired of it. I know every word, and I don’t even remember learning them; they’re just there. This isn’t a song you listen to occasionally — it’s one that becomes part of you if you’re a Billy Joel fan.
I’ve been to more than one Billy Joel concert where this song turns into something bigger than a performance. The band drops out, Billy barely has to sing, and the entire audience carries it from start to finish. Everyone knows it. Everyone. In those moments, it stops being his song and becomes ours. That’s when you realize you’re not just hearing a hit — you’re witnessing something permanent.
9. New York State of Mind (Turnstiles, 1976)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“New York State of Mind” did not crack the Top 10 on the Billboard Hot 100, peaking outside the upper tier when released in 1976. But, like “Piano Man,” this is a song whose Billboard-era importance far outgrew its initial chart position. It became a cornerstone of Billy Joel’s catalog through constant radio recurrence, live performances, and long-term cultural association—especially as his audience expanded nationally and internationally.
What earns this song its place in a Billboard-based ranking is identity value. Billboard history consistently elevates songs that come to define an artist’s voice and worldview, even when they weren’t explosive singles. “New York State of Mind” became essential listening on album-oriented rock and adult contemporary stations, and it helped solidify Joel’s credibility as more than a hitmaker. It positioned him as a songwriter with a clear sense of place, maturity, and restraint—qualities that would underpin his later chart successes.
Howard Dee’s Take
This is another one of Billy Joel’s staples — one of those songs that feels essential to who he is, even if it’s not one of my personal favorites. I completely understand why it ranks here. It’s thoughtful, restrained, and beautifully written. But it’s never been the song I gravitate toward when I want to feel Billy Joel.
That said, I love New York City, and this song absolutely captures what makes New York New York. It’s not loud or flashy; it’s reflective, grounded, and self-assured, just like the city itself when you really know it. Even if it’s not the song I reach for, I respect it deeply — and I wouldn’t tell the story of Billy Joel without it.
10. Only the Good Die Young (The Stranger, 1977)
Why This Song Ranks Here
“Only the Good Die Young” peaked at No. 24 on the Billboard Hot 100, which might seem modest compared to some of Billy Joel’s higher-charting singles. But, once again, Billboard impact isn’t just about peak position. This song became one of the most talked-about and controversial tracks of Joel’s career, generating sustained airplay, public debate, and long-term recurrence that far exceeded its original chart run. In Billboard terms, controversy often equals visibility — and this song never disappeared.
Its ranking is driven by cultural weight and endurance. Radio stations debated it, religious groups protested it, and listeners sought it out because it felt provocative without being cruel. Over time, it became a permanent fixture on classic rock and adult contemporary playlists, and it remains one of the songs most closely associated with The Stranger, Joel’s commercial breakthrough album. Billboard history consistently elevates songs that reshape an artist’s public perception, and this one absolutely did.
Howard Dee’s Take
I loved this song when it first came out. I was thirteen, and even at that age, I knew exactly what Billy was talking about. There was no subtlety lost on me — he was clearly trying to sleep with a good Catholic girl, and the fact that he wrapped that idea in wit and humor made it even better. It felt daring without being crude, which is a hard balance to pull off.
What I’ve always appreciated is how smart the poke at religion is. It’s not cruel or hateful — it’s aimed at the rules, not the faith itself. Billy isn’t attacking belief; he’s questioning rigidity and moral posturing with a wink and a grin. That’s why the song still works. It challenges authority without sounding angry, and it trusts the listener to get the joke — which, even at thirteen, I absolutely did.
Howard Dee’s Final Thoughts on Billy Joel’s Billboard Legacy
Looking back at this list, what stands out to me most is how little chart position has to do with why Billy Joel matters to me. Billboard tells you what songs were biggest at a moment in time, but it doesn’t explain why those songs stayed with you — or why some of them grew deeper as you did. Billy Joel’s career proves that success and substance don’t have to be at odds. He wrote hits, yes, but he also wrote songs people lived with.
Billy Joel has been the soundtrack to my life not because every song is my favorite, but because at every stage of my life, there was always a Billy Joel song that fit. Some hit me immediately. Others took years — even decades — to land. And a few I respect more than I love. That mix is exactly why this catalog holds up. It’s human, imperfect, confident, funny, thoughtful, and occasionally uncomfortable — just like life itself. Billboard captured the moments when the world was listening, but the real story is how long those songs kept playing after the charts stopped counting.
Explore More Bob Seger
Discover more about Billy Joel’s music, stories, and lasting influence through curated articles that dive deeper into their greatest songs, fascinating behind-the-scenes moments, and the legacy he left on 1970s music.
- The Life and Music of Billy Joel
- 10 Interesting Facts About Billy Joel
- Goodnight Saigon: A Lyric Deep Dive
- All Billy Joel Articles
More Top 10 Lists You’ll Love
- Top 10 Harry Chapin Songs
- Top 10 Bob Seger Songs
- Top 10 George Harrison Songs
- Top 10 Carole King Songs
Discover More ’70s Music Lists
Explore more rankings, deep dives, and curated lists from the greatest decade in music:
👉 Top 1970s Music Lists: Best Bands, Artists & Songs
Artist Resources
Frequently Asked Questions About Billy Joel’s Top Songs
What is Billy Joel’s most important song, even if it wasn’t his biggest Billboard hit?
While several Billy Joel songs reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100, “Piano Man” is widely considered his most important song. It defined his identity as a storyteller, introduced the character-driven writing style that would become his signature, and became inseparable from his public persona. Over time, its cultural impact far exceeded its original chart performance.
How many No. 1 hits did Billy Joel have on the Billboard Hot 100?
Billy Joel scored three No. 1 hits on the Billboard Hot 100: “It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me,” “Tell Her About It,” and “We Didn’t Start the Fire.” While that number may seem modest compared to some pop artists, his strength was consistency — dozens of Top 10 and Top 20 hits over nearly two decades.
Why do some Billy Joel staples rank high despite lower chart peaks?
Billboard rankings don’t rely solely on peak position. Songs like “Piano Man” and “New York State of Mind” gained stature through long-term radio play, cultural relevance, and live performance longevity. These songs became defining works that continued to chart indirectly through recurrence and influence long after their initial releases.
Did Billy Joel’s Billboard success change in the 1980s?
Yes, but not in the way many artists experienced decline. Billy Joel successfully transitioned into the 1980s with a harder sound (Glass Houses) and stylistic experimentation (An Innocent Man), continuing to earn No. 1 hits and heavy radio rotation. His Billboard success in the 1980s proved he wasn’t just a 1970s artist — he adapted without losing his audience.
Why is “Only the Good Die Young” considered one of Billy Joel’s most impactful songs?
Despite peaking outside the Top 20, “Only the Good Die Young” became one of Billy Joel’s most discussed songs due to controversy, protests, and sustained airplay. Its willingness to challenge social and religious norms increased its visibility and cemented its place in his catalog as a bold, defining moment.
What makes Billy Joel different from other chart-dominant artists of his era?
Billy Joel’s songs combined commercial appeal with narrative depth. Rather than chasing trends, he built hits around characters, places, and lived experiences. That balance allowed his songs to succeed on the charts while also aging well — a rare combination that explains why his music continues to resonate long after his final studio album.